Expert opinion

Why brokers are conflicted in the way they are incentivised

Alexei Garan, Head of Business Funding at Shaw & Co, explains why brokers are conflicted in the way they are incentivised by lenders.

2 minutes
January 26, 2022
Words:
Alexei Garan
Images:
Tim Gander Photography
PDF:
Report

"The majority of brokers are remunerated via fee sharing arrangements with lenders."
Alexei Garan
Head of Debt Advisory, Shaw & Co

The broker landscape covers a variety of activities and individual brokers have a wide range of industry backgrounds. While some brokers may look to earn fees directly from a client, the vast majority of brokers are remunerated via a fee sharing arrangement with the lender.

The problem here is that different lenders pay different percentages of their fees across to the broker.

A duty to fully disclose?

While there is a duty to disclose such arrangements, so the client is fully aware of who is getting paid what, it does not address the key concern. This is where a lender, who may not be presenting the best terms the market has to offer, is happy to share a disproportionate element of their fee to secure the opportunity.  

In the normal course of business, brokers will deal with lenders where they have a pre-agreed fee sharing / introducer arrangement. Rarely do brokers undertake a ‘whole of market’ review to include lenders where no ‘introducer agreement’ exists.

In some cases this could lead to clients taking on funding which may not be the most appropriate, or indeed accepting onerous conditions such as, among other things, the provision of personal guarantees. And, finally, while brokers can provide a useful conduit to lenders, it is always worth asking how many lenders have been approached during the process. A handful would suggest a less than rigorous approach…

Alexei Garan – Head of Business Funding at Shaw & Co
Alexei Garan – Head of Business Funding at Shaw & Co
We work with growing UK SMEs and small-cap PLCs that have funding needs in excess of £2m and regularly approaching £100m. Our clients’ needs will typically be for sophisticated finance products such as cash flow based lending or private equity investments. Our value lies in helping clients access funding that relies on confidence in future trading and cash flows. For a confidential, independent, no obligation discussion on the funding options available click the 'Let's chat' button.
Words:
Alexei Garan
 - 
Director
Read 
Alexei Garan
's bio

Sector Content

See all Shaw Reports
The Shaw Report - Manufacturing & Engineering Industry Annual Review September 2022

Shaw Report

|

September 1, 2022

The Shaw Report - Banking, Financial and Insurance Services Industry Interim Review August 2022

Shaw Report

|

August 23, 2022

The Shaw Report - Healthcare & Life Sciences Interim Review August 2022

Shaw Report

|

August 11, 2022

The Shaw Report - Food & Drink Annual Review July 2022

Shaw Report

|

July 22, 2022

The Shaw Report - Leisure, Tourism & Sport Interim Review July 2022

Shaw Report

|

July 19, 2022

The Shaw Report - Energy & Natural Resources Interim Review June 2022

Shaw Report

|

June 27, 2022

Shaw & Co launches annual analysis of wholesale & retail trade industry

Shaw Report

|

June 29, 2022

The Shaw Report - Automotive, Transport & Logistics Interim Review May 2022

Shaw Report

|

May 19, 2022

Shaw & Co Launches Annual Analysis of Property and Construction Industry

Shaw Report

|

May 6, 2022

The Shaw Report - TMT Interim Review May 2022

Shaw Report

|

May 5, 2022

The Shaw Report - Manufacturing & Engineering Interim Review April 2022

Shaw Report

|

April 8, 2022

The Shaw Report - Food & Drink Interim Review March 2022

Shaw Report

|

March 25, 2022

The Shaw Report - Professional Services Annual Review 2022

Shaw Report

|

March 17, 2022

The Shaw Report - Leisure, Tourism & Sport December 2021

Shaw Report

|

December 14, 2021

The Shaw Report - Health & Life Sciences December 2021

Shaw Report

|

December 10, 2021

The Shaw Report - Banking, Financial & Insurance Services December 2021

Shaw Report

|

December 8, 2021

The Shaw Report - Energy & Natural Resources November 2021

Shaw Report

|

November 16, 2021

The Shaw Report - Technology, Media & Telecoms October 2021

Shaw Report

|

October 28, 2021

The Shaw Report - Automotive, Transport & Logistics October 2021

Shaw Report

|

October 14, 2021

The Shaw Report - Manufacturing & Engineering October 2021

Shaw Report

|

October 1, 2021

The Shaw Report - Food & Drink September 2021

Shaw Report

|

September 27, 2021