Expert opinion

5 ways to successfully negotiate a Management Buyout (MBO) deal

Jim Shaw, CEO & Founder at Shaw & Co, shares his top tips on how to negotiate a management buyout (MBO) deal.

3 minutes
March 18, 2022
Words:
Jim Shaw
Images:
Tim Gander Photography
PDF:
Report

"Never forget that a MBO can be tricky."
Jim Shaw
CEO & Founder, Shaw & Co

Firstly, it’s important to define what we mean by a management buyout. It is usually defined as a management team agreeing to buy the business from the owner. However, sometimes a sale of a stake to private equity, wherein the existing owner is invited to co-invest, is also referred to as an MBO but here the dynamics are very different. Herein we are considering the former!

Never forget that a MBO can be tricky. As you have a buyer and a seller who work in the same company, reaching an agreement in terms of valuation can prove to be particularly challenging. Both parties may consider that they have some leverage and, if not managed carefully, this can become problematic.

If done properly, an MBO will provide the owners with an elegant way of extracting value while passing the baton (and future equity uplift) to the management team who were very likely a key component in the success of the business and are probably the best team to take it forward onto the next stage of its evolution. It can also enable an owner to step back gradually, selling the business while still retaining some of the equity.

Jim Shaw – CEO & Founder at Shaw & Co
Jim Shaw - M&A expert at Shaw & Co

Here are five key points to keep in mind when negotiating an MBO deal:

1 - Define the Vendor’s Role

It is important that the vendor’s role is clearly defined – they are the seller here, but they are also the business owner and potentially its founder and hold ultimate responsibility for the business until such time as it is sold. They need to tightly control the process to obtain the right offer and funding package to support it whilst protecting the value of their asset.

2 - Temper Financial Expectations

In general, price tends to be slightly lower as the vendor will not be taking the business to market and running a competitive bidding process. Private equity involvement can sometimes help bump up the numbers but equally if the vendor finds themselves in a debt backed MBO they may have to wait a few years for their money.

3 - Be Patient

An MBO is a transaction in which a company is purchased by management using their own cash resources, debt, external equity, vendor roll over (deferred consideration), or a combination of each, so it can be more complex than a sale or acquisition. It is also an extremely delicate transaction. It places the management team and shareholders in the opposing camps of buyer and seller. If handled incorrectly, an unsuccessful transaction can have a long- term negative impact on the business.

4 - Take Me to Your Leader

An MBO needs a clear leader in the management team. While agreeing on who the CEO should be and making sure they are strong enough is not an easy task, it is something that must be done well before an MBO is realistic. It is important to be able to present a credible management team to both the market and potential funders. The likelihood is that this will be their first MBO transaction (and probably their last) so getting it right first time will be critical for success.

5 - Don’t Forget the Day Job

The amount of distraction the MBO process can cause should not be underestimated. Key management still have their ‘day job’, while trying to juggle this with negotiating a good deal. This often creates tension between the MBO team and owners and having a corporate finance adviser who is able to act as a ‘circuit-breaker’ can alleviate much of this stress while helping negotiate, structure and fund a deal that is not only acceptable to all parties, but is also fundable.

We work with UK SMEs and small-cap PLCs that have the ambition to grow their business by acquisition. We often act as an outsourced Corporate Development team helping clients meet their strategic goals through mergers and acquisitions. Our value lies in helping clients build rigour into the acquisition search and execution process. For a confidential, independent, no obligation discussion on how to buy another business, click the 'Let's chat' button.
Words:
Jim Shaw
 - 
Founder & CEO
Read 
Jim Shaw
's bio

INDUSTRY Content

See all Shaw Reports
The Shaw Report: Leisure, Tourism & Sport - Interim Review #2

Shaw Report

|

June 27, 2023

The Shaw Report: Wholesale & Retail Trade - Annual Report #2

Shaw Report

|

June 27, 2023

The Shaw Report: Property & Construction - Annual Report #2

Shaw Report

|

May 30, 2023

The Shaw Report: Automotive, Transport & Logistics - Interim Review #2

Shaw Report

|

May 24, 2023

The Shaw Report: Manufacturing & Engineering - Interim Review #2

Shaw Report

|

May 10, 2023

The Shaw Report: Food & Drink - Interim Review #2

Shaw Report

|

May 9, 2023

The Shaw Report: Technology, Media & Telecoms - Interim Review #2

Shaw Report

|

April 17, 2023

The Shaw Report: Energy & Natural Resources - Annual Report #2

Shaw Report

|

March 28, 2023

The Shaw Report: Professional Services - Annual Report #2

Shaw Report

|

March 20, 2023

The Shaw Report: Banking, Financial & Insurance Services - Annual Report #2

Shaw Report

|

February 28, 2023

The Shaw Report - Healthcare & Life Sciences Annual Review December 2022

Shaw Report

|

December 14, 2022

The Shaw Report - Wholesale & Retail Trade Industry Interim Review December 2022

Shaw Report

|

December 14, 2022

The Shaw Report - Leisure, Tourism and Sport Annual Review November 2022

Shaw Report

|

November 29, 2022

The Shaw Report - Property & Construction Industry Interim Review November 2022

Shaw Report

|

November 23, 2022

The Shaw Report - Technology Media & Telecoms Industry Annual Review October 2022

Shaw Report

|

October 19, 2022

The Shaw Report - Automotive, Transport & Logistics Industry Annual Review October 2022

Shaw Report

|

October 12, 2022

The Shaw Report - Professional Services Industry Interim Review September 2022

Shaw Report

|

September 26, 2022

The Shaw Report - Manufacturing & Engineering Industry Annual Review September 2022

Shaw Report

|

September 1, 2022

The Shaw Report - Banking, Financial and Insurance Services Industry Interim Review August 2022

Shaw Report

|

August 23, 2022

The Shaw Report - Healthcare & Life Sciences Interim Review August 2022

Shaw Report

|

August 11, 2022

Food & Beverages Industry Report 2022

Shaw Report

|

July 22, 2022

The Shaw Report - Leisure, Tourism & Sport Interim Review July 2022

Shaw Report

|

July 19, 2022

The Shaw Report - Energy & Natural Resources Interim Review June 2022

Shaw Report

|

June 27, 2022

Shaw & Co launches annual analysis of wholesale & retail trade industry

Shaw Report

|

June 29, 2022

The Shaw Report - Automotive, Transport & Logistics Interim Review May 2022

Shaw Report

|

May 19, 2022

Shaw & Co Launches Annual Analysis of Property and Construction Industry

Shaw Report

|

May 6, 2022

The Shaw Report - TMT Interim Review May 2022

Shaw Report

|

May 5, 2022

The Shaw Report - Manufacturing & Engineering Interim Review April 2022

Shaw Report

|

April 8, 2022

The Shaw Report - Food & Drink Interim Review March 2022

Shaw Report

|

March 25, 2022

The Shaw Report - Professional Services Annual Review 2022

Shaw Report

|

March 17, 2022

The Shaw Report - Leisure, Tourism & Sport December 2021

Shaw Report

|

December 14, 2021

The Shaw Report - Health & Life Sciences December 2021

Shaw Report

|

December 10, 2021

The Shaw Report - Banking, Financial & Insurance Services December 2021

Shaw Report

|

December 8, 2021

The Shaw Report - Energy & Natural Resources November 2021

Shaw Report

|

November 16, 2021

The Shaw Report - Technology, Media & Telecoms October 2021

Shaw Report

|

October 28, 2021

The Shaw Report - Automotive, Transport & Logistics October 2021

Shaw Report

|

October 14, 2021

The Shaw Report - Manufacturing & Engineering October 2021

Shaw Report

|

October 1, 2021

The Shaw Report - Food & Drink September 2021

Shaw Report

|

September 27, 2021